QUOTE

Judging Step Three: The top three (3) entries in each category will go into one final poll to be voted on for the Grand Prize. The one with the most judge's votes in the final poll will be awarded Grand Prize.
In the event of ties, PoultryChamp will break the tie.

These are the entries for Category 3, Photography. Judging ends December 11th for this `round`, where the winner will be announced. Names will not be included but the title/desc and link to post will be.

Judging Rubric
Creativity: 40%
Originality: 20%
Skill: 30%
Effort: 10%
--------------------
100% / 100%









Title/Desc: "S-F Ranch Lakeside Fishing"
Link to Topic




Title/Desc: "A photo from when I was in egypt"
Link to Topic





Title/Desc: "Its snowing! Behind that snow is a street with a man walking on it. :P"
Link to Topic

Category 3, Entry 1
Judging Rubric
Creativity: 20 / 40%
Originality: 17 / 20%
Skill: 25 / 30%
Effort: 10%
--------------------
x% / 100%




Category 3, Entry 2
Judging Rubric
Creativity: 15 / 40%
Originality: 10 / 20%
Skill: 20 / 30%
Effort: 10%
--------------------
x% / 100%



Category 3, Entry 3
Judging Rubric
Creativity: 25 / 40%
Originality: 20 / 20%
Skill: 5 / 30%
Effort: 5%
--------------------
x% / 100%

Entry 1
Creativity: 35%
Originality: 15%
Skill: 25%
Effort: 10%
--------------------
85% / 100%



Entry 2
Creativity: 30%
Originality: 15%
Skill: 25%
Effort: 10%
--------------------
80% / 100%



Entry 3
Creativity: 30%
Originality: 15%
Skill: 20%
Effort: 10%
--------------------
75% / 100%



I believe the sunset/feeling of relaxation and fun in photo number one rings with the number 1 choice for me on this catagory.

Chosen entry three. I nominate it for the 'most seasonally appropriate' award.

Rationale

Entry 1
Creativity: 25% / 40%
Originality: 15% / 20%
Skill: 25% / 30%
Effort: 8% / 10%
--------------------
73% / 100%

__________________________________


Entry 2
Creativity: % / 40%
Originality: % / 20%
Skill: % / 30%
Effort: % / 10%
--------------------
% / 100%
__________________________________


Entry 3
Creativity: 26% / 40%
Originality: 12% / 20%
Skill: 28% / 30%
Effort: 8% / 10%
--------------------
74% / 100%

Entry 1
Creativity: 37%
Originality: 16%
Skill: 25%
Effort: 10%
--------------------
88% / 100%

Entry 2
Creativity: 27%
Originality: 13%
Skill: 21%
Effort: 10%
--------------------
71% / 100%

Entry 3
Creativity: 30%
Originality: 14%
Skill: 23%
Effort: 9%
--------------------
76% / 100%

Category 3, Entry 1
Judging Rubric
Creativity: 23 / 40%
Originality: 17 / 20%
Skill: 25 / 30%
Effort: 9/ 10%
--------------------
74% / 100%

Nice picture of a lake, I would liked to have seen a close up view of the boy fishing, and maybe isolated from the rest, would have received higher marks.


Category 3, Entry 2
Judging Rubric
Creativity: 15 / 40%
Originality: 13/ 20%
Skill: 20 / 30%
Effort: 7/ 10%
--------------------
65% / 100%



Category 3, Entry 3
Judging Rubric
Creativity: 25 / 40%
Originality: 13 / 20%
Skill: 10 / 30%
Effort: 7/ 10%
--------------------
55% / 100%


--------------------